TD: Calgary & Edmonton Housing Markets Likely To Correct

Oil driven housing markets like Calgary & Edmonton are likely to correct over the next two years according to TD’s latest regional housing outlook.

“A significant softening in job markets will set the stage for a second major housing correction in Calgary and Edmonton since 2008,” states the report.

“While results in the upcoming spring market will be helpful in estimating the magnitude of the likely correction in these two markets, our early reading points to a decline in average prices of roughly 10% over the next 4-6 quarters from their peak levels late last year, with stability returning to the market by mid-2016.”

TD Housing Forecast

TD Housing Forecast

TD predicts the average price of a Calgary home will fall from $459,500 to $439,500 in 2015 (-4.4%) and then to $424,500 in 2016 (-3.4%).    Sales are expected to plummet by -47% this year and -1.9% next year.

The report goes on to say: “Calgary and Edmonton have already experienced a sudden and abrupt turn, and by January, existing home sales had already slumped by 45% and 30% from peak levels reached last year, respectively. Meanwhile, annual average existing home price growth slid into negative territory.”

It’s too bad TD is focusing entirely on the average price which is a volatile and misleading measure in the context of the following facts:

  • Median price was up 1.08% y/y in January
  • Benchmark price was up 7.69% y/y in January
  • Teranet HPI which tracks repeat home sales was up 7.1% y/y in January
  • Luxury sales ($1M+) in January were down -42% y/y

If the Calgary real estate market continues on this path, price declines are obviously expected.  However, I think TD is jumping the gun by stating that prices have already slid into negative annual growth by referencing only the average price.

To download and read the entire report: click here pdf

 

2 responses to “TD: Calgary & Edmonton Housing Markets Likely To Correct

  1. Mike, today’s stats are perplexing to me. The median price rollup from Feb-14 to Feb-15 states an increase of 0.27% However, looking at the breakdown you see the following:
    Single Family: down $7500
    Condo Apartment: down $15000
    Condo Townhouse: down $35000
    CREB towns: down $7000
    CREB Country Realestate: down $64000

    So how does that all add up to an increase of 0.27%? Also, how come they’ve started putting NA into their Active Listings % column?

    Thx.

  2. Hello Kuato,

    Just because the median price is down across all categories, doesn’t always mean it’s down overall. The easiest way to explain it is using a made-up example:

    Detached median in 2015 ($200,000) was down -60% y/y.
    Apartment median in 2015 ($90,000) was down -10% y/y.
    But total median in 2015 ($200,000) was up +100% y/y.

    Regarding your second question about N/A in the CREB stats, here’s the answer.

Please feel free to post your comment or question

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s