BMO: Housing Market A “Balloon”, Not A “Bubble”

Yet another report out by BMO reassuring Canadians the housing market is fine and will just “cool rather than crash,” likening it to a balloon with a small amount of air slowly escaping.

They assert that the housing boom will more likely cool than correct, even in condo-driven Toronto, where it’s estimated that about half of all new condos in the GTA are purchased by investors, 22% of all condos are rented, and the cost of owning exceeds the rental income.  Sounds good.

“The [BMO] report suggests that alarms about Canada’s housing market by international observers, from the International Monetary Fund to The Economist magazine, are exaggerated or simplistic.” – Globe & Mail

The price-to-income ration for Canada as a whole in 2001 was 3.2.  It rose to 4.9 in 2011.

In Calgary the price-to-income ratio jumped from a healthy 2.8 to a 4.1 ten years later while home prices appreciated 118% during that time.

Despite this, BMO believes that with the exception of a few regions, valuations remain only moderately high across the country and that low interest rates will allow incomes to catch up with higher prices and restore proper valuations.  The wistful “soft-landing” scenario.

You can read the entire report here.  Please feel free to share your thoughts.

Canada facing subprime mortgage risk

In other news today, Bloomberg obtained 152 pages of documents under freedom of information law from the Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions that details how Canadian lenders are loosening standards and offering mortgages similar to U.S. subprime loans that pose an “emerging risk”.

Remember, it was only on Friday that BMO emphatically stated how “solid” CMHC is and how “prudent” their underwriting standards are.

You can read the Bloomberg article here

Let’s Rewind

You could easily replace “Bernanke” with “Sherry Cooper” and think the following is verbatim from a recent BMO report:

House of Representatives hearing, Feb. 15, 2006:

Mr. BERNANKE: “The housing market has been very strong for the past few years. Housing prices have been up quite a but. Residential investment has been very strong.

It seems to be the case — there are some straws in the wind that housing markets are cooling a bit. Our expectation is that the decline in activity or the slowing in activity will be moderate; that house prices will probably continue to rise but not at the pace that they had been rising.

So we expect the housing market to cool but not to change very sharply.

If the housing market does cool, more or less as expected, that would still be consistent with a strong economy. In 2006 and 2007, in particular, capital investment and other forms of demand would take up the slack left by residential investment.”

7/1/05 – Interview on CNBC
INTERVIEWER: Ben, there’s been a lot of talk about a housing bubble, particularly, you know [inaudible] from all sorts of places. Can you give us your view as to whether or not there is a housing bubble out there?

BERNANKE: Well, unquestionably, housing prices are up quite a bit; I think it’s important to note that fundamentals are also very strong. We’ve got a growing economy, jobs, incomes. We’ve got very low mortgage rates. We’ve got demographics supporting housing growth. We’ve got restricted supply in some places. So it’s certainly understandable that prices would go up some. I don’t know whether prices are exactly where they should be, but I think it’s fair to say that much of what’s happened is supported by the strength of the economy.

INTERVIEWER: Tell me, what is the worst-case scenario? We have so many economists coming on our air saying ‘Oh, this is a bubble, and it’s going to burst, and this is going to be a real issue for the economy.’ Some say it could even cause a recession at some point. What is the worst-case scenario if in fact we were to see prices come down substantially across the country?

BERNANKE: Well, I guess I don’t buy your premise. It’s a pretty unlikely possibility. We’ve never had a decline in house prices on a nationwide basis. So, what I think what is more likely is that house prices will slow, maybe stabilize, might slow consumption spending a bit. I don’t think it’s gonna drive the economy too far from its full employment path, though.

Read more in Business Insider’s:  30 Bernanke Quotes That Are So Absurd You Won’t Know Whether To Laugh Or Cry

9 responses to “BMO: Housing Market A “Balloon”, Not A “Bubble”

  1. Taking in to account the record low natural gas prices and the high debt loads of some Albertans, I would say there is significant risk that the Calgary market will correct. Let’s face it, it already has but it may go even further down. Low interest rates didn’t save the US housing market – I doubt it will save any market in Canada. Those who get in now are those who are least likely to be able to afford any income or expense fluctuations.

  2. Thanks for your thoughts, Bast. Approximately what % amount do you believe is a correction?

    Edit: Added some Bernanke quotes to the main post above

  3. I would say we’ve had about a 10% correction and we’ll be looking at at least another 10-15% by the time we’re done. Obviously not true for the $1million+ market…Calgary is a funny town. Those who got, got a lot. Those who don’t pretend they do.

  4. Thanks for your response, Bast.

    Relevant? Maybe not, but Sherry Cooper listed her $2.98M home in Toronto

    Still for sale: MLS Listing

    Another Sherry Cooper forecast from 2001:

    BMO Nesbitt Burns chief economist Sherry Cooper said the loonie’s slide is inexorable and she urged Canada to adopt a common currency with the United States.

    “What makes us think we can buck this tide? Let’s dollarize and get it over with while we still have something to bargain with,” she wrote in an e-mail sent to clients Thursday.

    She said if things carry on like they have, she could see the loonie at 50 cents US within 7 years.

  5. Pingback: A Bubble By Any Other Name… | Calgary Real Estate Review

  6. Pingback: A Bubble By Any Other Name… | Calgary Real Estate Review

  7. Yes, the normal price/income ratio is about 3. A ratio of 5 or so makes Canadian real estate subject to a serious setback, not a gentle adjustment. The math says a 40% drop will only return us to normal. Of course, a fall like that will overshoot as panic sets in. Sounds extreme, but it’s only the flipside of complacency when prices are severely overstretched to the upside, like they are in Vancouver.

  8. Pingback: TD: Canadian Housing “Ripe for a Correction” – But No Bubble | Calgary Real Estate Review

  9. Pingback: BMO Has Words Of Warning For Canadian Housing Market | Calgary Real Estate Review

Please feel free to post your comment or question

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s