Monthly Archives: October 2011

The Dangers of Low-for-Long Interest Rates

A feature article in this week’s Focus digest from BMO highlights the many risks involved in the prolonged period of low borrowing costs. This past week, the Bank of Canada decided to leave rates on hold for the 9th consecutive meeting and 13th straight month.

Here are the first 2 risks of 6 outlined in the report:

1) It encourages households to take on potentially excessive debt: While an extended period of low interest rates can give the illusion that a hefty debt load is manageable, even a small rise in rates can cause problems for many borrowers. Of course, this is a fact the Bank itself has oft mentioned, stressing that borrowers should not be lulled into a false sense of security that low rates are permanent, thus heightening the shock when rates inevitably rise.

However, actions speak much louder than words for the Bank—it doesn’t really matter how much the Bank scolds Canadians if it continues to offer the heavy-duty lure of near-record low borrowing costs. Household debt has risen almost non-stop over at least the past 20 years and to a record share of personal disposable income. Indeed, the Bank’s concern about household debt is likely one key reason near-term rate cuts are unlikely.

2) It risks inflating a housing bubble: Average home prices have more than doubled in the past ten years, and are up more than 20% in the past three years alone, both far above personal income growth. While affordability remains reasonable, the long stretch of solid gains could set the stage for more speculative activity.

You can read the rest of the report here

$2.7M Repairs Needed For Latest Leaky Condo

Resiance Corporation’s vision was ”to build a better world” but instead it has left dozens of condo owners to tackle an estimated $2,662,705 worth of repairs because of defects with the building envelope.

Resiance, now out of business, (remember Gateway Midtown?) was the developer of the 250 unit Gateway Garrison Green project located at 5605 Henwood St SW which was completed in 2006.  Yes, it’s only 5 years old.

What makes matters worse is that the residents have been advised that it is “unlikely” that the Alberta New Home Warranty Program will provide any coverage and that insurance doesn’t cover poor quality workmanship or builder defect.

You can read the special assessment FAQs on the Gateway Garrison Green public site here

-

In addition to this project, Resiance was the developer for:

June 2004: A Sound Investment: The Gateway at Garrison Green

House Price Index (HPI): August 2011

(Note: This is the first monthly release where Edmonton, along with Hamilton, Québec, Victoria and Winnipeg have been added to the House Price Index)

Canadian home prices in August were up 0.9% from the previous month, according to the Teranet–National Bank National Composite House Price Index™. It was the 9th consecutive monthly increase and the fifth of 0.9% or more. 6 of the 11 metropolitan markets surveyed were also at all-time highs. Year-over-year, Canadian prices were up 5.4%

Calgary prices were up +0.7% from the previous month and up +0.8% year-over-year. The Calgary appreciation broke a 9-month run of 12-month deflation.

In Edmonton, prices increased +0.6% m/m but remained down from a year earlier for a 10th consecutive month (−2.1%)

It’s great to see Edmonton join the index so we can compare Calgary’s market to it.  Edmonton boomed just after Calgary did, and to a greater extent.

(click to enlarge image)

I know it’s difficult to distinguish the cities in the spaghetti mess in the chart below, but Winnipeg has even surpassed Calgary’s 2007 high and is closing in on Edmonton’s peak before it corrected. Their increase, however, has been a more gradual incline rather than the spike seen in the Alberta cities.

(click to enlarge image)

Zoopraisal™ by Zoocasa

Zoopraisal™ is Zoocasa’s estimated market value of your home which can be used a starting point in determining a home’s price. The Zoopraisal™ service is provided through a licensing agreement with Centract Settlement Services which possesses one of the largest national databases of residential real estate prices and information in Canada. The Zoopraisal™ also provides additional content from the Zoocasa database and its content partnerships including detailed neighborhood demographics.

And did I mention, it’s free?

By entering the few required details seen below, it provides an estimated valuation of your home within a low & high range.

  • Address
  • Style (choice of Side-split, bungalow, condo, 2+ storey, townhouse)
  • Bed
  • Baths
  • Living Area
  • Lot Size
  • Year Built

But let’s put it to the test.  How accurate are the estimates?

To begin with, lets focus on the apartment-style condos that sold yesterday in Calgary.

Altadore River Park

Sold for: $235,000
Estimate: $247,237 
High: $261,000
Low: $234,000

-

Crescent Heights
Sold for:  $325,000
Estimate:  $311,114 
High: $336,000
Low:  $286,000

-

Discovery Ridge
Sold for:  $265,000
Estimate:  $260,752
High: $274,000
Low: $248,000

-

Downtown
Sold for: $95,000
Estimate:  $103,884
High: $122,000
Low: $88,000

-

Hillhurst
Sold for: $446,000
Estimate:  $431,558 
High: $482,000
Low: $382,000

-

Renfrew
Sold for:  $162,000
Estimate:  $204,396 
High: $242,000
Low: $167,000

-

Royal Oak
Sold for: $297,825
Estimate:  $306,021 
High: $333,000
Low:  $279,000

-

Shawnee Slopes/Evergreen
Sold for:  $230,000
Estimate:  $259,495 
High: $286,000
Low: $233,000

-

Sunalta
Sold for: $314,500
Estimate: $268,907 
High: $309,000
Low:  $228,000

-

West Dover
Sold for: $199,000
Estimate: $235,271 
High: $258,000
Low: $213,000

-
For estimating market value of condos, aside from a couple of quirky valuations, I was like:

For single family homes, it still needs some tweaking but that’s to be expected with something that was launched just last week.   It’s limited in house styles (no bilevels, 3 level splits, etc) and sometimes adding just an additional bedroom would bump up the value by $50k or more.

Give it a try:  click here

and then come back and let me know how it did appraising your home.

Strong Growth Forecast for Calgary in 2012

“...this growth comes with the caveat that the global 
economy stabilizes. Otherwise, all bets are off." 

Ben Brunnen, Chief Economist with the Calgary Chamber of Commerce, released an Economic Outlook that projects strong growth for Calgary but with many global risks. Brunnen’s Economic Outlook was featured at a Risk Management Association economic panel event this morning.

Despite continued global economic uncertainty, annual investment has grown in Alberta’s energy sector since 2009, suggesting companies expect oil prices to remain in a profitable range for the foreseeable future.

“Strong provincial energy industry investment combined with real GDP growth across most sectors suggests that Calgary’s economy will perform well into 2012 and 2013,” said Brunnen. “But this growth comes with the caveat that the global economy stabilizes. Otherwise, all bets are off.”

Calgary is Canada’s energy hub, whose fortunes are tied to global energy markets. Provincial energy sector investment has created favourable conditions for growth in the city.

“Calgary’s economy really turned a corner in 2010 with employment growth in most major sectors,” said Brunnen. “In 2011, the value of commercial building permits will increase for the first time since 2007, indicating a new phase of business expansion.”

The Economic Outlook predicts Alberta’s real GDP growth to be between 3.8 and 4 per cent in 2011 and slightly lower in 2012 and 2013 due to global economic concerns. For Calgary, GDP growth is forecast to be between 3 and 3.2 per cent in 2011 and between 3.1 and 3.3 per cent in 2012. Growth is expected to decline to between 2.9 and 3.1 in 2013, as conditions in the US and
global economies weaken.

Calgary’s unemployment rate is expected to close out 2011 at 5.8 per cent (down from 6.9 per cent in 2010) and continue to decline to between 5.6 to 5.8 per cent in 2012 and 5.7 to 5.9 per cent in 2013.

“Calgary experienced 11 consecutive months of total employment increases,” said Brunnen. “Though we are unlikely to return to the acute labour shortages of 2006 – 2008, a gradual tightening of Calgary’s labour market is expected.”

Key risks to the forecast include insufficient action to address the European debt crisis, a further slowdown in the US, and moderation in the Chinese economy.

“Calgary fared better than most during the Great Recession,” said Brunnen. “It continues to be one of the best places to live and do business in North America.”

-
You can read the full 24 page outlook here