BMO: CMHC Is Solid

In their most recent weekly financial digest, BMO economist Sherry Cooper adamantly states that the financial strength of Canada’s mortgage insurer, CMHC, is solid.

CMHC is fully funded and strong enough to withstand any reasonable (though improbable) stress test. In addition, CMHC is working closely with the Bank of Canada and the Department of Finance to analyze Canadian house prices by city (CMA) looking for warning signs of a potential bubble.

At the moment, there is little evidence to suggest a problematic overvaluation in the Canadian housing market overall, although some centres “warrant close monitoring.”

Read the entire article here

-
Other points of view:

Globe  & Mail:  There could be trouble on CMHC’s Horizon
Macleans: Canada’s mortgage monster

CIBC: Looking Beyond the Debt-to-Income Ratio

A new report by CIBC looks beyond the debt-to-income ratio of Canadians to assess how we really are doing financially.   Indeed, using simply the debt-to-income ratio to gauge the well-being of finances isn’t enough as there are some other countries with even higher debt loads that “have not experienced any grief.”

So CIBC took a look at the distribution of Canada’s household debt:

Looking at a unique data set that allows us to zoom in only on those households carrying debt, we found that all of the rise in debt since 2007 has been driven by borrowing from those with a high debt-to-gross income ratio using that measure rather than disposable income due to data limitations.

The indebted have piled on still more debt. Some 34% of households that have debt are now in the high-debt-burden category (defined as a ratio of 1.6 or above for debt to gross income) and they account for nearly three-quarters of household debt outstanding.

Not surprisingly, among those in debt, the share of those with high debt-to-income ratios is greater in provinces where housing is expensive (BC, Alberta and Ontario) as families have chased the home ownership dream in markets where price gains have outstripped incomes.

However, this is not to say that household bankruptcies are going to experience a sharp run-up since two necessary triggers are not currently present:  quickly rising interest rates and climbing unemployment.

But it does raise the spectre of a further deceleration in Canadians’ appetite and room for additional debt, as more reach the constraints of their ability to service debt. We have already seen a deceleration in consumer debt, which has sapped some of the stimulative impacts of the Bank of Canada’s low rate policy.

Housing might be next to feel the same pinch, with new construction and prices leveling off in the year ahead. That will leave Canada more at the mercy of the global environment, which remains clouded by the impacts of fiscal tightening across much of the developed world

One assumes that with rising debts, net worth and assets would rise alongside with it for the most part…

But much of the gain in total assets has been associated with rising market values for housing and land. If both mortgage debt and house price climbs are part of an unsustainable market overvaluation of housing fueled by unsustainably low mortgage rates, then the asset values could stall or even deteriorate, without a compensating change in debt outstanding.

And housing price gains do not really add to national well-being to the same extent as gains in other asset prices. As Bank of England Governor Mervyn King once pointed out, leaving aside foreign purchasers, a rise in house prices is mostly a transfer of wealth to those who own a house (i.e. the older generation) from those who will be buying one ahead. The former could sell their house and live off the proceeds, implying less need to save, but the latter have to save more to make their first house purchase.

You can read the entire report here

CIBC: ‘Soft Landing’ Will Still Impact Economy

In a new report out today, CIBC says that “even if house prices land softly, the impact on the economy in general, and construction jobs in particular, will be far from gentle.”

CIBC still reiterates that a housing market crash is not foreseen, but they believe that it’s likely that that real estate activity will level off soon.

Real estate has been an important engine of economic activity, with the number of high quality construction jobs rising by 3.5% in 2011. That is more than double the pace of employment gains seen in the economy as a whole. That momentum will be lost when the housing market levels off.

In terms of job creation and job quality, Alberta remains the bright spot in Canada.

The impact of a softening pace of job creation is exacerbated by a worsening level of job quality in the Canadian labour market…While our index is well above the level seen during the recession, it is down by more than one point over the past year.

By province, the largest drop was observed in Ontario, followed by British Columbia. In contrast, Alberta continues to generate high quality jobs at a rapid pace. (see chart below)

With both quantity and quality of employment falling in tandem, it is hardly a surprise that real disposable income was unchanged in the first three quarters of 2011—the worst showing in fifteen years.

Calgary’s labour market in particular continues to buck the national trend. In the most recent City of Calgary Labour Review, the report stated:

Looking back in 2011, Calgary and Alberta’s job markets outperformed the rest of Canada (chart 1), thanks to the continuous strength in crude oil prices and increasing importance of oil sands as a safe source of oil.

House Price Index (HPI): November 2011

For the 3rd straight month, Calgary home prices saw month-over-month declines according to the Teranet-National Bank House Price Index.  Between October and November, Calgary’s HPI fell -1.6%, the largest drop of the municipalities tracked.   Year-over-Year, house prices were up +0.5%

Canadian home prices in November were down -0.2%.  The retreat came after two months in which prices had been flat from the month before.  Year-over-year prices were up +7.1% (composite 11) or up 8% (composite 6)

The report also states that “the simultaneous monthly declines in Toronto, Hamilton and Winnipeg are noteworthy in that these three markets are considered tight.”

All indices have a base value of 100 in June 2005. For example, an index value of 130 means that home prices have increased 30% since June 2005.

Source: Housepriceindex.ca

MLS® Housing Price Index (HPI) Launching February 2012

Back in September, you first read about a national HPI that was to be launched in 2012.  We’re happy to say that the MLS® Housing Price Index (HPI) is coming to Calgary in February, as part of a nationwide rollout involving boards in Canada’s largest cities.

This new monthly price measure will enable us to better determine real price changes.  For example, many agents have experienced a scenario where the monthly average price increased by 5%, and our clients say, “Prices increased, shouldn’t my house be worth more?”

The 5% increase is often misinterpreted, and could be caused by a number of factors including a rise in luxury home sales. As average prices can be skewed by the composition of sales, it does not reflect price trends based on the type and features that a home provides.

The index will help as price trends will reflect changes caused by individual’s willingness to pay for home attributes.

What does this mean for those working with REALTORS®?

By using MLS® HPI, we will be able to offer more comprehensive and purer data than ever before – data you can use for property comparisons, understanding future price trends and estimating current market values.

So how does it work?

The MLS® HPI is calculated using a sophisticated statistical model that estimates home prices based on their quantitative and qualitative features, including:

•  Number of rooms above the basement level
•  Number of bathrooms and half-bathrooms
•  Square footage for main living and basement areas
•  Whether it has a fireplace and/or finished basement
•  Lot size
•  The age of the property
•  Parking
•  How the home is heated
•  Foundation, flooring, siding and roofing types
•  Whether the property has a waterfront or panoramic view
•  Whether the property has been sold previously
•  Proximity to shopping, schools, hospitals, police stations, churches, sports centres, golf courses, parks, and transportation (including train stations, airports etc.)

Upon valuating these features or attributes the index and the benchmark price are formulated.

MLS® HPI Benchmark

A ‘benchmark home’ is one that shows a set of attributes typical to the area/sub-market where it is located. Since ‘typical’ homes are different from one area to the next, their descriptions differ between areas.

If you’re interested in the benchmark home attributes that will be tracked by the MLS® HPI in your community, please email me with “Community Benchmark” as the subject, and the community you’re interested in.  The typical home for each community will remain constant over time, indicating that attributes will not change.

For example, the following table outlines some of the attributes that comprise a typical home for each of the following communities:

Community Hawkwood Edgemont Mount Royal
Property type 2 storey 2 storey 2 storey
Age of property 16 16 50
Finished basement Yes Yes Yes
Living area 1,164 1,234 1,537
Lot size 4,984 4,169 6,463
Above ground bedrooms 3 3 3
Number of covered parking spots 2 2 2
Number of full baths 2 2 3

The MLS® HPI benchmark price is calculated by taking the values determined by the model and applying it to these attributes for the ‘typical’ homes in each area. The value of these attributes is generated based on geographical groupings where the sales that have occurred are similar to each other, i.e.”homogeneous”.

Continuing with the above example, the following data would also be available for each community.

  Benchmark Price % change one month % change six months % change one year % change three years
Mount Royal – two storey $1,320,774 0.69 -5.23 -4.61 -7.05
Hawkwood – two storey $410,286 1.27 -0.63 4.61 -0.58
Edgemont – two storey $477,760 -0.58 -2.30 4.29 3.03

As noted in the table above, the price of a two-storey home and its attributes vary from each community as do the trends in pricing. This type of monthly summary report will include each community by property type and will be available after the HPI launch in February.

I look forward to helping you with your real estate needs with this added tool at my disposal.